Most job offers have more room in them than the first number suggests, and most employers expect a counter — it rarely damages a relationship when it's done professionally. The goal isn't to extract every possible dollar; it's to make sure you're not leaving money or terms on the table simply because asking felt uncomfortable.
Never negotiate over text or in the moment on a phone call you weren't expecting. "Thank you so much — could I have a day to review the full offer?" buys you time to respond thoughtfully instead of reactively.
Don't negotiate based on a verbal number alone. Ask for the complete offer in writing — base salary, bonus structure, equity if applicable, benefits, and start date — so you're negotiating against the real picture, not just the headline figure.
"Thank you again for the offer — I'm genuinely excited about this role and the team. Based on my research into market rates for this position, along with my experience in [specific relevant skill or achievement], I was hoping we could discuss a base salary closer to [specific number]. Is there flexibility there?"
Notice what this does: it opens with genuine enthusiasm (not just a demand), gives a concrete reason for the ask, states a specific number, and ends with a question rather than an ultimatum — leaving room for a real conversation.
If the base number truly has no flexibility, other parts of the offer often do:
A specific number backed by real data is far more persuasive than a round number pulled from nowhere. Sites like the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Glassdoor, and Levels.fyi (for tech roles) give you a defensible market range to reference, so your counter sounds like it's grounded in research rather than an arbitrary ask.
A firm "no" on salary doesn't have to be a dead end. It's reasonable to ask directly: "I understand there's no flexibility on base salary right now — is there room to revisit this at a future review?" Getting that follow-up conversation acknowledged, ideally in writing, gives you something concrete to point back to later even if nothing moves today.
Almost never, as long as the negotiation is reasonable and professional. Rescinding a signed offer over a normal counter is rare and generally reflects poorly on the employer, not the candidate.
A specific number, or a narrow range where your lowest acceptable figure is still one you'd genuinely be happy with — a wide range invites the employer to anchor to the bottom of it.
Sometimes. A posted range often has some flexibility, especially near the top of it for a strong candidate, though heavily regulated roles (government, some union positions) may genuinely be fixed.
Shift the conversation to other terms — start date, extra PTO, a signing bonus, remote flexibility, or an earlier performance review — since these are often more flexible than the base salary line itself.
Source: CareerOneStop, sponsored by the U.S. Department of Labor. careeronestop.org
Still applying elsewhere? Build a matching cover letter too.